Global Stocks Soar On Chinese Economic Optimism

Over the weekend China reported a key inflection point in its manufacturing PMI , which had its first expansionary print in 5 months, and the market saw right through this attempt to generate optimism that global economic headwinds are finally abating, and promptly sold off.

Just kidding, April fools!

As happens every single time, global stocks surged higher on Monday, extending gains from their best quarter in nearly 10 years, as algos and traders dutifully ignored the fact that every single number out of China is carefully goalseeked and politically motivated – in this case meant to shift the trade war balance of power in favor of China whose economy is now on the rebound despite the ongoing US tariffs – and overnight global markets were a sea of green as “Chinese economic optimism” is now the dominant narrative, taking over from “US-China trade talk optimism.”

As we reported previously, on Sunday China’s NBS said that the country’s manufacturing PMI rebounded strongly in March from a contractionary 49.2, printing at 50.5, its first expansion since September 2018, and beating estimates of a 49.6 reading. The non-manufacturing PMI continued its recent improvement, rising to 54.8, also the best reading since last September, as both the services and construction PMIs strengthened, and resulted in the composite PMI rising to 54.0 from 52.4.

Predictably, Asian stocks, European bourses and S&P 500 futures all jumped as traders woke up to news of “strong manufacturing data” out of the world’s second largest economy which helped ease investor worries about a slowdown in global growth.

Just as predictably, analysts were effusive in their praise of this goalseeked Chinese number:

  • “Investors’ sentiment seems to be tilting to the side of optimism at the beginning of the second quarter, following a robust manufacturing report from China,” said Konstantinos Anthis, head of research at ADSS. “This news helps ease market participants’ worries over the odds of an upcoming recession on a global scale, even though there are plenty of signs suggesting caution,” Anthis said.
  • China’s PMI reading “was encouraging,” said Thomas Harr, global head of fixed income and commodity research at Danske Bank. “There is still a good chance that global and euro-zone growth will improve in coming quarters, as the U.S. and China will reach a trade deal, while the Fed’s dovish shift and China’s stimulus will help.”

Confirming China’s renaissance, the private Caixin/Markit PMI business survey released on Monday also showed the manufacturing sector in the world’s second biggest economy returning to growth.

The immediate result was investor euphoria which swept across Asia as MSCI’s index of Asia-Pacific shares outside Japan added 1%, Chinese shares surged 2.6% to the highest since May, while Hong Kong stocks entered a bull market. Australian stocks climbed 0.6 percent, South Korea’s KOSPI gained 1.3 percent and Japan’s Nikkei advanced 1.4 percent.

“The rebound likely reflects both the resumption of production after the Chinese New Year break and renewed stimulus and policy easing,” UBS strategists wrote in a note to clients. “We expect China to continue easing policy, with signs of economic stabilization backing our overweight position on offshore Chinese equities in our Asia portfolios” they added.

Asian optimism quickly went global as European stocks posted their best daily gains since mid-February, as the pan-European STOXX 600 index surged 0.8% in early trading. Germany’s trade-sensitive DAX outperformed with a 1 percent rise helped by gains in auto maker stocks as European carmakers advanced more than 2 percent. That’s despite manufacturing data for Europe coming in at the lowest since 2013, which briefly caused the euro to pare some of its gains.

The German manufacturing Purchasing Managers Index slipped to 44.1 in March, worse than a flash reading of 44.7 that was already well below economist estimates. With sentiment at Asian factories stabilizing, German bonds fell, pushing the yield on 10-year securities up 3 basis points to minus 0.04 percent at 9:34 a.m. Frankfurt time.

French manufacturing also shrank more than expected as the PMI there was revised down to 49.7, however all this was generally ignored in light of the newly-found Chinese economic optimism.

As Bloomberg notes, global equities are building on their strongest quarter since 2010 amid bets that dovish tilts by major central banks will help prop up earnings. The Chinese data went some way toward easing worries about a slowdown prior to the release of American monthly jobs numbers at the end of the week, while Treasury 10-year yields have also increased. U.S.-China trade talks will resume when Vice Premier Liu He leads a delegation to Washington later this week, potentially offering more positive developments for investors.

China’s recovery pushed yields higher, and the closely watched 3-month/10-year yield spread has pulled back from negative territory and stood around 3 basis points after investing two weeks ago.

In currencies, the dollar traded lower versus most of its G-10 peers after better-than-expected China data eased concern global growth was slowing. The Bloomberg Dollar Spot Index dropped 0.2%, snapping a four-day winning streak amid strong demand for upside exposure through options; it briefly pared losses after German mfg PMI data misses estimates, before falling to a new day low amid strong risk sentiment. Major emerging-market currencies advanced while sterling gains ahead of a U.K. parliamentary debate on various Brexit options.

Sterling was 0.6% higher to the dollar at $1.3114 on Monday, after taking its latest knock after British lawmakers rejected Prime Minister May’s Brexit deal for a third time on Friday. The Australian dollar advanced 0.45 percent to $0.7127, also benefiting from the China data. The Aussie is sensitive to shifts in the economic outlook for China, the country’s main trading partner.

Treasury 10-year yield climbed as much as 4bps to 2.4475%; Risk-sensitive currencies lead gains in the G-10, while the yen drops; Antipodean and Scandinavian currencies gain along with China’s yuan as Chinese Vice Premier Liu He scheduled to lead a delegation of trade negotiators to Washington on Wednesday after officials held talks in Beijing. The yen declined, while the Turkish lira slipped initially as preliminary results from the weekend’s municipal elections showed that Turkey opposition party claimed victory in Istanbul and Ankara, while the ruling AK Party also initially claimed to have won in Istanbul following local elections over the weekend which was seen as a referendum on President Erdogan. However. President Erdogan later commented that although the Mayorship may have been lost in Istanbul, they won in many of its municipalities; the lira initially slumped lower before it exploded higher after it emerged that Turkey is once again cracking down on shorts as the overnight swap rate surged to 260%.

In commodities, oil prices rose, adding to gains in the first quarter when the major benchmarks posted their biggest increases in nearly a decade, as concerns about supplies outweigh fears of a slowing global economy. Crude oil prices added to Friday’s gains, with U.S. West Texas Intermediate futures gaining 0.9 percent to $60.69 per barrel. Brent was 1.3 percent higher at $68.46 per barrel.

Economic data include retail sales, ISM manufacturing, construction spending and business inventories.

Market Snapshot

  • S&P 500 futures up 0.8% to 2,859.75
  • STOXX Europe 600 up 1.1% to 383.38
  • MXAP up 1% to 161.44
  • MXAPJ up 1% to 534.46
  • Nikkei up 1.4% to 21,509.03
  • Topix up 1.5% to 1,615.81
  • Hang Seng Index up 1.8% to 29,562.02
  • Shanghai Composite up 2.6% to 3,170.36
  • Sensex up 0.9% to 39,024.05
  • Australia S&P/ASX 200 up 0.6% to 6,216.96
  • Kospi up 1.3% to 2,168.28
  • German 10Y yield rose 4.5 bps to -0.025%
  • Euro up 0.3% to $1.1248
  • Italian 10Y yield rose 0.2 bps to 2.134%
  • Spanish 10Y yield rose 3.7 bps to 1.134%
  • Brent Futures up 1.7% to $68.71/bbl
  • Gold spot down 0.1% to $1,290.74
  • U.S. Dollar Index down 0.3% to 97.04

Top Overnight News from Bloomberg

  • IHS Markit’s Purchasing Managers’ Index for Germany slipped to 44.1 in March, worse than a flash reading of 44.7 that was already well below economist estimates
  • U.K. manufacturers intensified stockpiling last month as they prepared for Brexit. IHS Markit’s Purchasing Managers Index rose to 55.1 in March, the highest since February 2018, from 52.1 the previous month, the firm said on Monday
  • The Chinese government said it will extend a suspension of retaliatory tariffs on U.S. autos and include the opioid fentanyl in a list of controlled substances, two steps that could generate a positive atmosphere for trade negotiations due to resume this week. Beijing temporarily scrapped the 25 percent tariff imposed on vehicles as a tit-for- tat measure on Jan. 1, after the White House delayed a rise in tariffs on $200 billion of products that had been due that day
  • Saudi Aramco was the world’s most profitable company in 2018, easily surpassing U.S. behemoths including Apple Inc. and Exxon Mobil Corp., according to an extract of the firm’s accounts published by Fitch Ratings
  • Asset managers switched to net long NZD from short, CFTC data for week ended March 26 show. Leveraged funds raised their net GBP long positions and boosted net EUR shorts

Asian equity markets began the new quarter on the front-foot with momentum sustained from last Friday’s global rally in which the S&P 500 notched its best quarterly performance in nearly a decade and as the region also cheered encouraging Chinese PMI data. ASX 200 (+0.6%) and Nikkei 225 (+1.4%) gained from the open in which Consumer Staples led the broad gains across Australia’s sectors after Woolworths completed the sale of its petrol business and announced to return funds through a AUD 1.7bln off-market buyback, while the Japanese benchmark shrugged off a weak Tankan survey and was among the best performers with risk appetite fuelled by favourable currency flows. Hang Seng (+1.8%) and Shanghai Comp. (+2.6%) were uplifted by strong Chinese data in which the Official Manufacturing, Non-Manufacturing and Caixin Manufacturing PMIs all topped estimates with the official reading in expansionary territory for the first time since October. Furthermore, trade optimism and the inclusion of China’s onshore bonds in the Bloomberg Barclays Global Aggregate Index from today further added to the optimism with the mainland firmly extending on the over-3% gains seen on Friday and with the Hang Seng now in bull market territory. Finally, 10yr JGBs were lower amid similar weakness in T-notes and as a rally across riskier assets dampened safe-haven demand, while the BoJ recently announced its purchase intentions for the month in which it kept all amounts unchanged.

Top Asian News

  • Analysts Downgrade China’s Stocks at Fastest Clip Since 2011
  • Why Trump’s Sale of Fighter Jets Designed in 1970s Spooks China
  • China Stocks Start April With Bang, Bonds Slide After Data Boost
  • Philippine Stocks Falls Most in Asia as World Bank Cuts Forecast

A stellar start to the week for European stocks [Eurostoxx 50 +0.7%] following an inspiring performance in Asia where mainland China advanced in excess of 2% on the back of optimistic China manufacturing PMIs. Broad-based gains are being seen across major European indices, although Germany’s DAX (+1.5%) modestly outperforms peers, driven forward by the likes of auto names [Daimler +3.5%, Volkswagen +2.6% and BMW +1.8%] after Chinese PMIs topped estimates. Furthermore, the release also bolstered other China exposed sectors, i.e. luxury names, with Swatch (+1.4%), Richemont (+0.8%), LMVH (+1.0%) all performing well in their respective bourses. Sectors are also showing broad-based positivity, although utilities are underperforming as investors move away from defensive stocks. In terms of notable movers, WPP (+3.2%) rests at the top of the FTSE after a Deutsche Bank upgrade, whilst easyJet (-7.9%) shares declined after company CEO warned of a cautious H2 outlook as he expects softer yields from UK and European tickets.

Top European News

  • Euro-Area Inflation Slows as Core Measure Falls to 11-Month Low
  • Turkey Election Board Says Opposition Leading Race in Istanbul
  • U.K. Parliament Seizes Control Amid Brexit Rift in May’s Tories
  • U.K. Factory Index Climbs to 13-Month High on Brexit Stockpiling
  • Korian Shares Fall After Deaths at French Retirement Home

In FX, AUD/NZD/GBP/NOK/SEK – All beneficiaries of forecast-beating PMIs, albeit indirectly in the case of the Antipodean Dollars, as encouraging Chinese surveys overnight lifted broad risk sentiment and the Aussie and Kiwi accordingly. Meanwhile, a significantly better than expected UK headline print was mainly boosted by further pre-Brexit stock-piling, although output, new orders and jobs sub-components also improved and activity in both Scandi manufacturing sectors expanded at a faster pace. Hence, Aud/Usd and Nzd/Usd are both looking firmer above big figure levels at 0.7100 and 0.6800 respectively, with the former also probing above its 50 DMA (0.7119), while Cable extended its rebound from last week’s lows and back over 1.3000 to circa 1.3100, breaching its 55 DMA (1.3075) on the way. However, the latest round of IVs present more risk and uncertainty for the Pound with up to 8 amendments up for selection around 2.30 pm before debates and voting tonight – for a more detailed schedule and analysis see our headline feed. Elsewhere, Eur/Nok is back down below 9.6500 and Eur/Sek sub-10.4000 to test multi technical support levels including the 30 DMA (10.3844), 200 DMA (10.3812) and the bottom of a chart cloud (10.3785). Back down under, and the Aud will be looking for independent impetus via the RBA tomorrow with options pricing a 35 pip break-even for the event – full preview also available via the headline feed.

  • EUR/CHF – Also firmer vs the Usd as the DXY retreats towards 97.000 again, but capped around 1.1250 and 0.9935 respectively in wake of relatively downbeat PMIs and Swiss retail sales.
  • CAD/JPY – The G10 laggards, as the Loonie meanders between 1.3340-30 vs its US counterpart and the Jpy pivots 111.00 amidst the aforementioned general revival in risk appetite post-Chinese PMIs, and with the headline pair also underpinned by a downbeat Japanese Tankan report. However, 111.20 is holding (just) and represents a 61.8% Fib retracement of the 112.13-109.70 downmove.
  • EM – Contrasting fortunes for the Lira and Rand, as weekend municipal elections in Turkey saw some key losses for the ruling AK Party to main opposition CHP, but not enough to threaten President Erdogan’s overall majority and result in regime change. Usd/Try has been up to 5.7000+ in response vs Usd/Zar that has been as low as 14.2225 after Moody’s delayed its latest credit review of SA and any potential cut in the rating and/or outlook, for the time being at least.

In commodities, the upbeat sentiment emanating from the optimistic China metrics overnight has supported sentiment alongside the demand outlook for the energy complex. Brent futures are marching with gains of around USD 1.0/bbl while WTI futures advance over USD 0.50/bbl. Brent oil has reached levels last seen in November, and from a technical front, the 200 DMA for Brent resides around USD 69.68/bbl and around USD 61.50/bbl for WTI. Furthermore, BAML expects Brent to average USD 74/bbl in Q2 2019, and USD 70/bbl in 2019. Meanwhile, the bank sees WTI averaging USD 56/bbl in 2019 and USD 60/bbl in 2020. Elsewhere, the latest CFTC data shows that speculative net long NYMEX WTI by almost 26k lots over last week, with a bulk of the buying coming from fresh longs. Of note, this month sees the EIA short-term energy outlook release on the 9th, OPEC monthly report on the 10th and IAE oil market report the day after. It is also worth noting that traders will be keeping an eye on trade developments as US is to host a Chinese trade delegation on the 3rd. In metals, gold prices succumbed to the positive risk tone as the yellow metal remains below the USD 1300/oz, albeit off lows. Meanwhile, the aforementioned China data bolstered copper prices to levels just shy of USD 3.00/lb, to levels last seen in June 2018. Elsewhere, iron ore prices have been supported by the Caixin-beat alongside a force majeure by Rio Tinto which will result in a loss of around 14mln tonnes of production this year. As such, Goldman Sachs raised iron ore price forecasts with 3-month estimate at USD 85/ton (Prev. USD 80), 6-month estimate at USD 80/ton (Prev. USD 75/ton) and 1-year estimate at USD 70/ton (Prev. USD 65).

US Event Calendar

  • 8:30am: Retail Sales Advance MoM, est. 0.3%, prior 0.2%; Retail Sales Ex Auto MoM, est. 0.3%, prior 0.9%
    • Retail Sales Control Group, est. 0.3%, prior 1.1%
  • 9:45am: Markit US Manufacturing PMI, est. 52.5, prior 52.5
  • 10am: ISM Manufacturing, est. 54.5, prior 54.2;
  • 10am: Construction Spending MoM, est. -0.2%, prior 1.3%
  • 10am: Business Inventories, est. 0.5%, prior 0.6%

DB’s Jim Reid concludes the overnight wrap

Happy April Fool’s Day, the day I first met my wife 9 years ago. Insert your own gag here. I can guarantee she has no idea of this anniversary. The problem or advantage (depending on your view) with doing a market’s related April Fool’s is that there have been so many strange things happen over the last few years that nearly anything could be true! Anyway I hope you all had a good weekend. On Saturday I played golf in shorts in the blazing sun and on Sunday I took the family out for Mother’s Day lunch to find that tables were only available outside. Problem was that it was freezing as the weather had completely turned. A lot of tears followed. The children were also upset. The clocks also went forward here in Europe and my wife thinks it must have been a male conspiracy to ensure that Mother’s Day was only 23 hours long this year.

There is some good news to start the week and the new quarter as yesterday saw the crucial Chinese manufacturing PMI number rise to 50.5 from 49.2 last month, the biggest increase since 2012 and beating all consensus estimates. Sub components that are very closely watched for forward looking momentum – new orders (51.6 from 50.6) and new export orders (47.1 from 45.2) – both rose to the highest levels in six months. The non-manufacturing also rose to 54.8 from 54.3 last month and 54.4 expected. The composite number increased from 52.4 to 54 the highest since September 2018. Overnight, China’s Caixin March manufacturing PMI also beat expectations at 50.8 from 49.9 last month (50.0 expected). The accompanying commentary along with the Caixin release said that the sub-index for new orders climbed to its highest level in four months while the new export orders returned to expansionary territory. Given the recent domestic stimulus – which our rates strategist Francis Yared has written about being around half the size of the growth bursting 2016 version – we have been expecting a bounce back in China but it had been a little elusive until now. The data could have elements of lunar holiday distortions depressing the comparisons from February but for now it will be a tentative welcome relief for global growth, especially for the Europeans. Our Chinese economists point out that we’ll know more as to whether this is an upswing when March’s activity data is released on April 17th.

In response, Chinese equities are leading the gains in Asia with the Shanghai Comp (+2.29%), CSI (+2.31%) and Shenzhen Comp (+3.03%) all up. The Nikkei (+1.72%), Hang Seng (+1.65%) and Kospi (+1.18%) are also up alongside most Asian markets. The Japanese yen is down -0.17% this morning and the yield on 10yr JGBs is up +1.4bps to -0.087%. Elsewhere, futures on the S&P 500 are up +0.63% and the 2yr and 10yr treasury yields are both up c. +3bps this morning.

Overnight China’s government has said that it will extend a suspension of retaliatory tariffs on US autos and include the opioid fentanyl in a list of controlled substances. The moves comes ahead of a visit by China’s Vice Premier Liu He later in the week to the US for continuing trade talks. The statement from China’s Minsitry of Finance said that the move seeks to “continue to create a good atmosphere for China-U.S. economic and trade talks” and is a “positive response” to the U.S. decision to delay tariff increases.

Elsewhere over the weekend, we had local elections in Turkey yesterday where President Erdogan’s party lost in the country’s capital Ankara and key cities along the Mediterranean coast while retaining its control in rural interiors and Istanbul (Bloomberg). The Turkish lira is down c. 1% overnight as market participants remain concerned about the ruling party announcing further populist policies to shore up declining support. Ahead of the elections, the BIST 100 equity index fell -6.1% last week, its worst weekly performance since October. The overnight swap rate ended the week at 28.98%, having risen over 1300% during last week.

Moving on to Brexit, over the weekend Conservative Party Deputy Chairman James Cleverly told Sky News on Sunday that the Tories are taking “pragmatic” steps to prepare for an election. He added though that it’s not the central plan, but the party is making preparations nonetheless. Meanwhile, the latest opinion polls are showing that the support for the opposition Labour party is now turning around with the Deltapoll/ Mail on Sunday poll indicating that the Labour party (at 41%) now leads the Conservative party (at +36%) in polls. Another opinion poll released over the weekend by Opinium & The Observer showed both parties at 35%. Will the market start to worry again about a left wing U.K. government? Elsewhere, the Sun reported on Saturday that some 170 Tories, including 11 cabinet ministers, wrote to May on Friday urging a no-deal departure on April 12. In terms of timeline for today’s vote on alternative options, House of Commons speaker John Bercow will announce the exact motions to be debated today at 2:30pm and the plan is to conclude the debate at 8:00 pm and then hold votes. Sterling is trading down +0.08% this morning.

As we start Q2, the European PMIs this morning will be the key event, especially after the disappointing flash numbers around 10 days ago. If China is turning up it might be too early for this to filter into these numbers so maybe disappointment over any softness will be tempered for now given the China strength. The equivalent number in the US will also be important later on. Elsewhere politics can be expected to remain on the agenda, both with the latest trade talks between the US and China, as well as any further Brexit developments which today sees a second round of indicative votes but as the week roles on could see us closer to a fresh general election. Brexit continues to be a high stakes game with no obvious way to resolve it. As ever March’s US payrolls report (Friday) will also be a highlight, as will the minutes from March’s ECB meeting (Thursday) especially given the perceived communication mis-step at that time. As for the rest of the upcoming events we’ll have the full day by day week ahead at the end.

This morning my colleague Craig has got back from his holiday on the West Coast of the US and has just published the Q1/March asset performance review. I mistakenly mentioned on Friday that he had gone skiing and completely forgot that him and I had a long conversation about his trip along the US coast just before he went away. Good man management. Nick in my team is off this week and I think he’s actually gone skiing but perhaps he’s on safari in Africa!! Anyway see here for the full performance review report but suffice to say it was a quarter to remember just as 2018 was a year to forget. Indeed, Q1 ended with 37 out of the 38 assets in our sample finishing with a positive total return in local currency terms, and 35 out of 38 assets in dollar adjusted terms doing so. Picking out some of the highlights at an asset level, this was the best quarter for WTI Oil (+32.4%) and the S&P 500 (+13.6%) since Q2 2009, US HY (+7.5%) since Q4 2011, the Shanghai Comp (+23.9%) since Q4 2014 and the STOXX 600 (+13.3%) since Q1 2015. In fact we had 11 assets end Q1 with double digit returns, the most since Q1 2012. Very impressive and 2018 and Q1 2019 are an illustration as to the impact central banks are still having on global markets in both directions.

Global equities ended the quarter by advancing last week on a bit of a wall of worry as rates plunged. The S&P 500 rose +1.20% (+0.67% Friday), with the STOXX 600 +0.81% (+0.60% Friday). Government bond yields continued to fall, with German ten-year bund yields deeper into negative territory as they lost -5.5bps to settle at -0.072%. US ten-year yields fell -3.4bps, ending the week at 2.41%, although the 2s10s curve steepened +2.1bps last week to close at 14.7bps. Positive sentiment also lifted oil prices, with Brent Crude +2.03% (+0.84% Friday).

Data generally supported the positive sentiment on Friday, with German retail sales rising unexpectedly in February by +0.9% mom (vs. -1.0% expected), while the country’s unemployment rate also fell to 4.9% in March, its lowest rate since German reunification. In the US, the final University of Michigan consumer sentiment index for March rose to 98.4 (vs. 97.8 expected). Ahead of today’s Eurozone inflation reading for March, Friday also saw the French harmonised reading at 1.3%, its lowest since February 2018, while in Italy, harmonised inflation remained at 1.1%.

The latest word from the US-China trade talks was positive on Friday with China’s official Xinhua News Agency saying on Friday that “new progress” had been made in the talks with US Trade Representative Lighthizer and Treasury Secretary Mnuchin in Beijing. Mnuchin described the discussions as “constructive”. Further talks will be taking place this week as Chinese Vice Premier Liu He visits Washington next week for further discussions.

via ZeroHedge News https://ift.tt/2JWKwwZ Tyler Durden

Flights Grounded Across US As Airlines Report Mass System Outages

Flights at airports across the US have been cancelled Monday morning as Delta, Southwest, American, United and Alaska Air all reported widespread system outages, per reports on social media.

The glitch is believed to involve Aerodata, a system that monitors weight and balance issues for planes. Due to the outage, flights aren’t receiving clearance to take off. Southwest, United and Delta have confirmed the outages and are posting apologies and explanations to frustrated customers on social media, including this response by Delta.

The organizers of ‘furry convention’ warned participants to check their flights before arriving at the airport.

Could this be some kind of April Fools’ Day hack?

This is a developing story…

via ZeroHedge News https://ift.tt/2YHQsNy Tyler Durden

Sterling Surges As MPs Prepare For 2nd ‘Indicative Vote’

Tired of the Commons’ interminable bickering and Theresa May’s ineffectual leadership, Brussels warned last week that the UK will ‘likely’ leave Europe without a withdrawal deal on April 12 after the third ‘meaningful vote’ on May’s withdrawal agreement failed by a margin of 58 votes. Though that margin has shrunk considerably since the first two votes, it’s becoming increasingly clear that there’s no way May can pass the deal, even if she does manage to bring it back for a fourth vote ahead of the emergency Brexit summit that begins on April 10.

PM

What’s worse, an ‘indicative vote’ on Brexit alternatives forced by backbencher MPs last week affirmed the Tory leadership’s suspicions that no alternative to May’s deal could garner a majority of support in the Commons, as none of the eight options on the ballot manged to secure a majority of votes (MPs were asked to vote ‘yes’ or ‘no’ on each listed option).

MPs

Per BBG

Though the indicative vote only further muddied the waters, the Commons is planning to hold another round on Monday, albeit with a slightly different slate of alternatives, as MPs reportedly rally around a ‘softer’ Brexit deal that would call for the UK to remain in the customs union after Brexit Day.

If this, too, fails, the likelihood that May will at least formally call for a general election, an option that she is loathe to consider, will rise. Though most Tories will likely insist that May step down before they support another general vote (last time around, when May called a general election in the summer of 2017, it ended up being perhaps the biggest political miscalculation of her tenure at No. 10).

Even if Monday’s second indicative vote does produce a majority of support for a modified Brexit arrangement, it’s doubtful that the EU would accept it so late in the game. May would likely need to ask for a lengthy Brexit extension – which she may or may not get.

In any event, the pound has rallied on Monday amid reports that at least 40 Tory MPs are preparing to support the customs union alternative, which is also expected to garner support from the opposition.

GBP

Debate begins at 3:30 pm (10:30 am ET), with voting expected to start around 8 pm  (3 pm). Here are the options that Speaker Bercow is expected to select (text courtesy of CNN):

Motion A, Unilateral right of exit from backstop — This proposes that the UK shall leave the European Union on May 22 with the Withdrawal Agreement amended to allow the UK unilaterally to exit the Northern Ireland backstop.

Motion B, No deal in the absence of a Withdrawal Agreement — This alternative calls for support from MPs for a no-deal Brexit if the House has not backed May’s Withdrawal Agreement.

Motion C, Customs Union — This motion calls on the Government to ensure that the Brexit plan includes a permanent and comprehensive UK-wide customs union with the EU.

Motion D, Common Market 2.0 – This proposal wants the Political Declaration – which covers the future relationship between the UK and the EU – to be renegotiated so that the UK joins the European Free Trade Association, through which is retains its membership of the European Economic Area, or Single Market. The UK would also seek to negotiate a “comprehensive customs arrangement” with the EU.

Motion E, Confirmatory public vote – Parliament would not be allowed to ratify any Brexit deal until it has been confirmed by a public poll.

Motion F, Public vote to prevent no deal — Calls for a second referendum on exiting the European Union, if a no-deal scenario appears likely.

via ZeroHedge News https://ift.tt/2Uhg7xq Tyler Durden

Beijing Orders 200 Ships To Spratly Islands, Provoking Panic In Manila

What appears to be Beijing’s latest military flex in the South China Sea – the contested collection of shoals and reefs that plays a crucial role in global trade and also contains vast untapped gas reserves – has reportedly set off “alarm bells” in Manila, just as the Philippines and the US were preparing to begin a round of military drills. According to Bloomberg, Philippines personnel have lodged a complaint with a joint Chinese-Flippino commission created to resolve disputes in the region, after authorities counted a mass of 200 Chinese ships around the Thitu, the second-largest island in the Spratly Islands.

Thitu

With a trade deal still in limbo, military tensions in the South China Sea have intensified as the US Navy has stepped up the pace of its “freedom of navigation” operations, while Beijing has stepped up its threatening rhetoric toward Taiwan and carried out more military drills.

A Philippines official said the ships appeared to be part of China’s sea militia. Philippine President Rodrigo Duterte’s spokesman Salvador Panelo said he would meet China’s ambassador and ask for an explanation for the bolstered presence, after the Philippine Foreign Affairs Department lodged its protest with the committee.

Philippines

Per BBG:

Philippine soldiers will continue their patrols in the disputed area, military chief General Benjamin Madrigal Jr. told reporters separately, adding that Chinese fishing vessels have repeatedly been spotted near the island. He urged a panel with representatives from both nations tasked with resolving South China Sea disputes to address Chinese presence in the area.

“This is a concern not only for the military, but for other agencies as well, including the Coast Guard. We are looking for ways to address this,” Madrigal told reporters on the sidelines of opening ceremonies for annual joint military drills between the Philippines and the U.S.

Before Duterte came to power and opted for warmer ties with Beijing, Manila won a case in the ICC validating its claim to sovereignty over most of the South China Sea. However, Beijing has ignored this ruling (and faced zero repercussions for doing so).

However, the ships massing around Thitu (which is known by Pagasa in the Philippines) wasn’t China’s only provocation. Taiwan accused Beijing of sending Navy ships across the median line of the Taiwan Strait, violating a long-held tacit agreement.

via ZeroHedge News https://ift.tt/2TLFcMK Tyler Durden

Forcing MV4: Binary Brexit Choice Versus Conspiracy Theories & Accidents

Authored by Mike Shedlock via MishTalk,

Readers propose some interesting ideas on Brexit. I also discuss how May can force MV4 over the will of Bercow.

Reader Views

  1. Conspiracy Idea: What would May have done different if she wanted to create an exit plan that Parliament would vote down at every turn?

  2. Accident Idea: I think you underestimate the insider will of a majority of UK MPs who instead of the accidental hard Brexit will deliver an accidental revocation of Article 50, which then means UK participating in EU elections.

The theory behind viewpoint number one is that May is purposely doing everything she can so that her deal is voted down and the UK stays in the EU. This can be on her own accord or with the explicit help of the EU, I don’t know which, so we will explore both ideas (May acting by herself and May acting with the help of the EU).

The result of theory number 2 is the same as number although it does not propose May is doing this on purpose.

Conspiracy Ideal Rebuttal

The immediate problem with #1 is an assumption of guilt. It’s like saying drug pushers always obey traffic signals and do not speed then concluding that everyone who does the same is a drug pusher.

Even if May would not have done anything differently, one cannot assume guilt, especially compared with the simple notion that May is a fool who does not know how to negotiate.

Second, May’s actions dramatically increase the odds of no-deal.

Don’t Take Macron For Granted

The single biggest risk to the entire process remains astonishing ignorance of facts and a narcissistic tendency to indulge in silly procedural games in the House of Commons.

We believe the UK should not take for granted the possibility of a longer extension. Emmanuel Macron is the most vocal member of the European Council to insist there will be only a short delay unless there is a clear majority for an alternative mandate. This has not happened yet. Also, even if the UK were to propose a second referendum a longer delay is not guaranteed. Nathalie Loiseau, who leads Macron’s party into the European elections, called a second referendum a denial of democracy. Even if it is only her personal view, you can imagine that this argument will have some traction in France and elsewhere.

The situation therefore remains highly dynamic. We would urge readers to distrust the argument that a no-Brexit cannot happen on the grounds that the UK parliament has voted to take it off the table.

Those comments are from Eurointelligence. They echo similar comments that I have made.

May’s actions, unless Macron and other are in on the grand scheme, dramatically increase the odds of no-deal. The UK parliament cannot take that off the table.

If May wants either a soft Brexit or a no-deal she can deliver. Instead, she sticks with her binary choice option at risk of an accident unless Macron and Juncker are in on it. The more people involved the messier it becomes.

If May has acted alone, she increased the odds of no-deal. Thus, she would not have followed the precise path she took.

Is Macron’s Threat Believable?

  • Yes! France picks up seats in the European parliament, Germany doesn’t.

  • France and Germany are at odds on the way forward in the EU. The UK sees things more like Germany. It is in the French best interest to have the UK out of the EU.

  • France wants a European Army. The UK doesn’t want the cost.

  • Neither France nor Germany wants UK representatives like Nigel Farage disrupting things. Theresa has no control over UK representatives in the European parliament.

My base assumption is that France now wants the UK out of the EU, it just does not want the blame. Yet, things have no gotten so ridiculous, France may be willing to take the blame.

Accident Idea Rebuttal

Unless the UK parliament votes to hold EU parliament elections by April 11 and Macron sticks to his guns, there won’t be EU parliament elections and there will not be a lengthy extension either.

For reasons noted above, France does not want the UK in the parliament. France has no choice if two things happen.

Long Extension Request Requirements

  1. The UK agrees to parliamentary election by April 11

  2. The UK parliament votes for an option that May will accept and that the EU accepts, again by April 11.

Those could happen, but there is no particular reason to believe both of those will happen.

On the probability of a No-Deal Brexit

In his FT column, Wolfgang Munchau [Eurointelligence founder] makes the argument that a no-deal Brexit is possible even if it is nobody’s first choice. He says the probability of a no-deal Brexit has grown since the EU summit last week. For starters, Theresa May can have a no-deal Brexit if she wants to. The UK parliament does not have the legal tools to stop it. One of the biggest and most persistent misunderstandings about Brexit is that the whole business of extension is between the prime minister herself and the European Council.

There is a reasonable chance that the indicative votes won’t get the job done. The Tories have no mechanism to oust her now. A parliamentary vote of no-confidence is technically possible, but too much of a nuclear option to be credible. Munchau’s overall conclusion is that a no-deal Brexit is not the first choice of any of the decision-makers involved, but the more relevant point is that they are not ready to pay a high political price to avoid it.

The likelihood of a no-deal Brexit has risen further in the last few days, as the European Council appears resigned to that outcome.

The odds of a referendum have collapsed. Not even Labour leader Corbyn wants that outcome. He does want a customs union.

Perhaps there is support for a customs union, but that alone is insufficient. May has to agree to it.

One of the biggest and most persistent misunderstandings about Brexit is that the whole business of extension is between the prime minister herself and the European Council.”

The UK parliament cannot and has not taken no-deal off the table. Nor has the UK parliament taken control of anything.

Accidents Can Happen

Interestingly, MPs who believe they have taken no-deal off the table and MPs who believe May has to accept the results of non-binding indicative votes along with delusional Remainers hoping for another referendum, increase the odds of an accident.

That accident will not be a referendum, but rather “no-deal”.

Meaningful Vote Three Goes Down 344-277: The Result Isn’t Meaningful

On Friday, I commented Meaningful Vote Three Goes Down 344-277: The Result Isn’t Meaningful

Support for May’s Deal Increases

People who voted against the deal at Meaningful Vote 2 but for it this time include: Lucy Allan, Richard Bacon, Crispin Blunt, Conor Burns, Rehman Chishti, Simon Clarke, Damian Collins, Rosie Cooper, Robert Courts, Richard Drax, Iain Duncan Smith, Charlie Elphicke, Michael Fabricant, Sir Michael Fallon, Jim Fitzpatrick, James Gray, Chris Green, Mark Harper, Gordon Henderson, Eddie Hughes, Boris Johnson, Gareth Johnson, Daniel Kawczynski, Pauline Latham, Andrew Lewer, Ian Liddell-Grainger, Jonathan Lord, Esther McVey, Anne Main, Sheryll Murray, Tom Pursglove, Dominic Raab, Jacob Rees-Mogg, Grant Shapps, Henry Smith, Royston Smith, Bob Stewart, Ross Thomson, Michael Tomlinson, Craig Tracey, Anne-Marie Trevelyan, Shailesh Vara, and John Whittingdale.

Rebels

34 Tories voted against the deal, five Labour MPs backed the deal.

Scorecard Analysis

May’s deal lost 344-286. That’s a total of 58 votes, but it’s closer than it may look. May needs to filp 29 votes and DUP is wavering.

More Brexiteers Fall in Line

The lead image shows two more hard Brexiteers supporting May’s deal, announced today.

Boris Johnson and others no-deal Brexiteers came out supporting May’s deal earlier this week.

On Friday, Brexit Central founder, MP, and hard core Brexiteer Jonathan Isaby published this Brexit Central editorial: Why I’ve reluctantly concluded that MPs need to vote for Theresa May’s deal.

Threats as a Means to an End

Theresa May still has the means to pressure either Labour or the Tories by one of three means.

  1. Threaten to resign immediately

  2. Threaten to back a customs union

  3. Tell Labour and the Tories that she will not honor indicative votes. Rather they have to choose between her deal and no deal.

Threat 1 puts Labour at the risk of Boris Johnson if they do not vote for her deal.

Threat 2 puts Tories at risk of a customs union.

The problem with threat 1 is hard core Tories would love to have May out of the picture.

The problem with threat 2 is no one in Labour would then vote for her deal.

However, the threats can be combined or mitigated behind the scenes.

For example, May can go to select Tories and threaten action 2 without stating so publicly. In this option, she would only talk to those on the fence, threatening a Customs Union.

Watch for a UK vote on EU parliament elections. That needs to happen by April 11, if it is to happen at all.

Option number three would cause huge disruption in Parliament, but if that is what May wants, she can have it.

Meaningful Vote #4 – Binary Choice

It is easy to believe believe that May is a poor negotiator and all she wants is a Binary Choice.

Moreover, May’s actions are consistent with the Binary Choice theory not conspiracy silliness or even act-alone ideas.

As such, and given the obvious nervousness of many Tories (and likely some Labour as well) it is highly likely there will be a meaningful vote number four.

Forcing MV4

Can may force MV4?

Yes, despite what Commons Speaker Bercow says, and despite any indicative votes.

Even assuming there is Parliament support for a customs union, all May has to do to force MV4 is go to Europe to “discuss” things then come back on April 10 with reasons she did not accept Parliament’s plan.

She can blame the EU for any number of reasons, real or imagined.

MV4 would happen in a flash.

MV3 was important in one regard. May now knows just how many votes she needs to pick up.

My Expectation

If Parliament cannot come to agreement by April 11 or if May manages to delay the final Meaningful Vote until then (and she has a means to do just that), she can then force Parliament to the binary choice that she wanted all along: My Deal or No-Deal with no time left to do anything else.

With no time left, MV4 would likely pass, reluctantly, with enough support from Labour. Alternatively, no-deal would win out. Either way, May would then resign, effective May 22.

via ZeroHedge News https://ift.tt/2I4Oyku Tyler Durden

Global Trade Takes Sharp Turn With Biggest Drop Since 2009

According to the Netherlands Bureau for Economic Policy Analysis (CPB), world trade plunged to its weakest levels not seen since the financial crisis.

The report published last week shows world trade expanded by 2.3% in January after the index tumbled in 4Q18. The recent rebound was broad-based with the strongest seen in emerging markets Asia (+6.2%), which followed a decline of -6.5% in December.

The three-month global trade momentum shows a downward trend of -1.8%, indicating economic growth across the world continues to slide into 2Q. Bloomberg said, “that’s the biggest drop since May 2009.” On a y/y basis, global trade posted its first decline in nearly nine years in the three months.

The global 1H19 outlook remains in a cyclical downturn, which could hinder world trade further. The epicenter of the slowdown originates in China, which is partly due to a combination of China’s growth supercycle coming to an end, developed world economies slowing, Federal Reserve tightening monetary policy, and the US-China trade war that disrupted supply chains in Asia. This has global consequences:

” For example, eurozone manufacturing PMI weakened to 47.6 in March according to Markit, marking the second consecutive month this year that manufacturing activity and export orders declined in the eurozone. The indices for January and February indicate contracting manufacturing activity in most of the east-Asian economies as well,” said ING.

Transitioning into the 2Q, significant downside dangers are developing. Trade negotiations between Washington and Beijing have been a no deal trade situation at every meeting. With a no deal expected at the upcoming meeting this week, trade talks could go into several more rounds before an agreement is hammered out.

If a no deal scenario plays out in 2Q, a further escalation in tariffs or just the lack of removing the duties could spark another growth fear and a repricing event of financial assets, similar to late last year.

Another concern is the standoff between President Donald Trump and Europe on auto tariffs. If Washington and Brussels cannot come to a resolution in the next several months, U.S. tariffs on European automobile imports would crush global trade further.

Uncertainties around NAFTA  countries remain, Canada and Mexico are still unsure if they are exempt from these tariffs.

via ZeroHedge News https://ift.tt/2UgXgm8 Tyler Durden

Brickbat: A Mother’s Love

Child in car seatFormer Long Beach, Mississippi, police officer Cassie Barker has pleaded guilty to manslaughter in the death of her 3-year-old daughter. Barker left the girl in a car seat in her patrol car while she had sex with her supervisor at his home. Barker left the air conditioning on but it wasn’t blowing cool air and the girl overheated.

from Hit & Run https://ift.tt/2CKu8tC
via IFTTT

This Is the Algerian End Game That Has Oil Investors Worried

Authored by Damir Kaletovic via Oilprice.com,

Protests that erupted six weeks ago in Algeria have now transformed into a million-strong force against aging Algerian strongman President Abdelaziz Bouteflika, with Exxon having already called the political unrest endgame when it stalled talks over a major Algerian shale deal just over a week ago.

For investors in this oil- and gas-rich venue that is critical most immediately to Europe, the uncertainty is high enough to put everything on hold.

Mass protests across Algeria erupted when Bouteflika announced he would run for a fifth term as president. Those protest forced him to rescind that decision, but the momentum against him failed to subside. Instead, it has increased and intends to do so until he steps down entirely.

On Friday, news wires around the world reported that a million had gathered to protest against the president’s rule, with fighting a losing battle using tear gas.

But what signals Bouteflika’s doom more than anything is the fact that the million-strong protests were covered live on three state TV channels. Traditionally, there would have been a local media blackout.

In other words, Bouteflika is losing support—quickly—and now everyone is watching the military kingmakers to see where this ends.

In large part, the kingmakers have already spoken, which has given further impetus to the protests. Earlier this week, the army chief called for a constitutional process to declare the aging and ill Bouteflika unfit for office.

But for investors, what happens next is a tricky transition process, for which opposition leaders have agreed to a roadmap, but for which uncertainty is the ruling element.

The current presidential appointment ends on April 28, and the opposition is suggesting the creation of a presidential authority body that would be in power for less than six months and whose representatives would not be allowed to run for office or back any candidates after the transition period.

via ZeroHedge News https://ift.tt/2I8nMaZ Tyler Durden

Saudi Arabia Went On Arms Buying Rampage Over Past 2 Years: Study

Despite Saudi Arabia coming under intensified international scrutiny after last year’s brutal murder of journalist Jamal Khashoggi inside the Saudi consulate in Istanbul, a new study shows Riyadh has been on a record-setting weapons buying spree over the past two years

And who supplies most of these arms? Of course the United States, which has by all indicators done nothing to curtail its perpetual arms pipeline to the Saudis; instead it has grown. According to a new 2019 study published in March from arms transfer monitoring group, the Stockholm International Peace Research Institute (SIPRI), 70 percent of the Saudi arsenal now comes from the United States.

Prior file photo of Saudi officers take photos during a joint military exercise of 21 Muslim nations (in 2016). Image source: Getty

Furthermore, the Saudis have hands down led the world in global weapons purchases for the past two years, and there’s little sign this trend will let up as Riyadh keeps up its merciless bombing campaign over neighboring Yemen, and as its regional ambitions have grown in competition with perceived “Iranian influence” — also given Syria’s Assad emerging victorious in the long-running proxy war in Syria, and as Hezbollah is now considered stronger than ever

Senior researcher and Middle East specialist with SIPRI, Pieter Wezeman, told PRI the US-Saudi arms trade has continued to grow: “There’s been a very significant growth in arms supplies to Saudi Arabia by the US,” he said.

He detailed the bulk constitutes major weapons systems as follows:

To Saudi Arabia, the US supplies a very wide range of arms. The most important types of arms include combat aircraft, tanks and missiles. It includes very advanced sensors and intelligence gathering equipment, often on planes. In the coming years, it will also include frigates and other ships. So, really, the whole package of weapons which Saudi Arabia wants to have is what the US is willing to supply and already has supplied.

Wezeman also suggested the Saudis are worried about Iranian escalation in Yemen. Saudi officials have long accused Tehran of transferring ballistic missiles to Shia Houthi rebels, in order to strike at targets deep inside Saudi Arabia. 

“What would have happened if one of those ballistic missiles would have killed many hundreds or if it would have killed a high-level royal family member?” Wezeman mused in his comments to PRI, reflecting Saudi fears. 

He explained further that Saudi motives for its arms buying rampage of the past years remain largely concealed, leaving analysts to speculate on the more obvious geopolitical factors: “We don’t have a nice Saudi Arabian defense whitepaper which clearly explains why they want to have all these arms,” he said. “We have to look at how they behave, statements made here and there by important Saudi Arabian people, in particular, the crown prince.”

Wezeman added: “And it is quite clear that the prime motive of motives for Saudi Arabia are that it wants to be a regional power and that weapons are considered an important tool for becoming that, and that it sees Iran as an important competitor in that struggle for regional power.”

Elsewhere the SIPRI study reported that the United States remains by far the world’s undisputed lead weapons supplier, growing exports by 29% between 2009–2013 and 2014–2018. The report found and the US share of total global exports went from 30% to 36% during the same period of comparison. 

Via SIPRI: The trend in international transfers of major weapons, 1979—2018.

More significant is the degree to which the United States is far outpacing Russia in the midst of what some observers have lately dubbed the “new Cold War”

According to the report:

The gap between the top two arms-exporting states also increased: US exports of major arms were 75 per cent higher than Russia’s in 2014–18, while they were only 12 per cent higher in 2009–13. More than half (52 per cent) of US arms exports went to the Middle East in 2014–18.

‘The USA has further solidified its position as the world’s leading arms supplier,’ says Dr Aude Fleurant, Director of the SIPRI Arms and Military Expenditure Programme. ‘The USA exported arms to at least 98 countries in the past five years; these deliveries often included advanced weapons such as combat aircraft, short-range cruise and ballistic missiles, and large numbers of guided bombs.’

One interesting data point regarding Russia’s lagging behind in global arms sales relates to Venezuela and India: “Arms exports by Russia decreased by 17 per cent between 2009–13 and 2014–18, in particular due to the reduction in arms imports by India and Venezuela,” the report noted

Image source: Bloomberg

Meanwhile US Congress has lately signaled it would try to put greater distance between Washington and Riyadh military cooperation, along with seeking answers to Saudi complicity in the Jamal Khashoggi murder — efforts which the White House has appeared to stonewall at every turn

Thus for now it appears “business as usual” will remain concerning the decades long US-Saudi arms pipeline. 

* * *

The Stockholm International Peace Research Institute (SIPRI) further found the following other notable developments:

  • Between 2009–13 and 2014–18 arms imports decreased by states in the Americas (–36 per cent), in Europe (–13 per cent), and in Africa (–6.5 per cent).
  • Algeria accounted for 56 per cent of African imports of major arms in 2014–18. Most other states in Africa import very few major arms.
  • The top five arms importers in sub-Saharan Africa were Nigeria, Angola, Sudan, Cameroon and Senegal. Together, they accounted for 56 per cent of arms imports to the subregion.
  • Between 2009–13 and 2014–18 British arms exports increased by 5.9 per cent. In 2014–18 a total of 59 per cent of British arms exports went to the Middle East, the vast bulk of which was made up of deliveries of combat aircraft to Saudi Arabia and Oman.
  • Venezuelan arms imports fell by 83 per cent between 2009–13 and 2014–18.
  • China delivered major arms to 53 countries in 2014–18, compared with 41 in 2009–13 and 32 in 2004–2008. Pakistan was the main recipient (37 per cent) in 2014–18, as it has been for all five-year periods since 1991.

via ZeroHedge News https://ift.tt/2HSoY2B Tyler Durden

Brexit’s Message To The European Union

Authored by Amir Tehari via The Gatestone Institute,

With the Brexit saga’s denouement still uncertain, the European Union would do well to re-examine its performance as a daring experience in socio-political engineering on a grand scale. Even if, as expected, the United Kingdom somehow manages to fudge Brexit and remain tied to the EU, the fact remains that millions of Brits and other Europeans are unhappy with aspects of the experience.

The first problem with the EU is that, though it is called a union, it isn’t really one. To be sure it has a flag, an anthem, a parliament, a council of ministers, and even pseudo-embassies in many countries, but despite such trappings of a state, the EU is essentially an economic club; not a state.

Even then, the EU is basically concerned with two branches of the economy: industry and agriculture, sectors that represent around 32 percent of the combined gross domestic product (GDP) of the 28 member states. In the case of Britain, which is primarily a service-based economy, industry and agriculture account for around 25 percent of GDP.

The EU’s annual budget accounts for around one percent of the total GDP of its 28 members. However, on average, the state in the 28 member countries controls the expenditure of around 50 percent of GDP.

Key aspects of the economy, including taxation, interest rates and, apart from members of the Eurozone, national currencies are not within the EU’s remit.

The EU’s member states represent many different historical memories and experiences.

The British are shaped by two centuries of colonial experience, followed by a brief flirtation with social-democracy morphing into the Thatcherite version of capitalism caricaturized in a single word: greed. The EU’s Nordic members emerge from seven decades of social democracy with “welfare” as the key concept.

Germany and Austria pride themselves in their “social market” economic model, which is regarded with deep suspicion in other European countries.

Italy, and to a lesser extent Greece, Spain and Portugal have a “black-and-white” model in which the unofficial or black economy is almost as big as the official one.

The Benelux three, Belgium, Holland, and Luxembourg have lived with what they call “social capitalism” — a system in which the principal role of the state is redistributing the wealth created.

France, depending on the party in power at any given time, has vacillated between the German-Austrian and the Benelux models.

The Central and Eastern European members were all parts of the Warsaw Pact and the Soviet-dominated Comecon and used to expecting the state and the party in control, to take all decisions and cater for all needs.

The 28 member states also have different political systems, ranging from traditional monarchies to republics with a revolutionary background and nations emerging from the debris of empires.

They also have long histories of enmities with one another. Leaving aside a long history of wars, some lasting over 100 years, little love is lost between the French and the Germans or the British for that matter. For the Hungarians, the number-one hated people in the world are the Romanians who still rule over four million “captive Hungarians” whose territory they annexed in 1919.

The Irish love the Brits as much as the Dutch love the Germans, that is to say not very much. Italians still remember oppression under the Austrians and the Spanish haven’t forgotten their struggle against Napoleon.

It is a wonder that the EU has managed to bring together so many nations in a region that has the longest and most intense history of national rivalries and enmities compared to any other region in the world. Part of that success was due to fears fomented by the Cold War and hopes risen after the fall of the Soviet Empire.

The Western European nations felt they needed to set aside old enmities to face up to the Communist “beast from the East”. In the post-Soviet era, the Central and Eastern European nations hurried to join the EU and NATO to put as much blue water as possible between themselves and their Russian former oppressors.

Needless to say, the United States encouraged the formation of the original Common Market and supported its morphing into the EU as part of a grand strategy to contain the USSR. In that context, the EU played a major role in ensuring peace and stability in a continent that has witnessed most of the wars that humanity has seen in its history.

The EU has also done a great job with the so-called mise à niveau (bringing up to standard) policy of helping new members achieve some measure of parity with the founding members in key fields of the rule of law, democratic values, economic regulations, and international behavior.

Brexit has highlighted the key challenges that the EU faces. The first challenge concerns a widespread overestimation of the EU’s role. This is due to its perception as a supra-national state which it certainly is not. Local politicians in many member states like to blame the EU for their own failings even in domains that do not concern the union.

The EU is also facing the challenge posed by the return of the nation-state as the most popular model of socio-political organization across the globe. Right now all supra-national and/or international organizations, from the United Nations to NATO, are regarded with suspicion, if not outright hostility, not only in Europe but also throughout the world.

EU leaders and those who support it would do well to offer a more modest and realistic image of the union as an economic club concerned with just certain aspects of its members’ economies and not as a putative “United States of Europe.”

The EU has been pretending to be a machine trying to impose uniformity on nations that have always prided themselves in their specificity. It may survive and even prosper if it works for unity in diversity.

Even if it never actually happens, the message of Brexit to the EU is: Pull down thy vanity!

via ZeroHedge News https://ift.tt/2CQjrpf Tyler Durden